A quoted probability and a realizable trade are different things. Before treating any screen as a decision aid, distinguish the displayed market value from the ask you would pay to buy and the bid you could receive to sell. Polymarket explains that its display generally uses the bid-ask midpoint, with a last-trade exception for a wide spread; neither is a promise of a fill. Its price explanation is the starting point.

Read the book, not just the card

Suppose a purely illustrative YES book has a $0.58 best bid and $0.62 best ask. The $0.60 midpoint may look like a bargain against a 64% model estimate, but a buyer at the ask has only a two-percentage-point gross difference before other costs. If only a few shares are offered at $0.62, the remainder of a larger order may fill at a worse price or not at all. Polymarket says an order book can lack enough counterparties for the desired size without materially moving price; see its liquidity explanation.

For a planned size, only if enough displayed depth exists, allocate planned shares across offer levels and calculate the weighted average fill as the sum of each level's price × shares filled there, divided by total planned shares. If depth is insufficient, label the remainder unfilled instead of inventing a fill price; a displayed book is not a guarantee. Repeat for the exit side if your thesis involves selling before resolution. Depth can change between inspection and execution. A limit order can control the maximum purchase price, but it might not fill; an unfilled opportunity is not realized profit.

Fees are contract-specific and changeable

Do not use “free trading” or one fixed fee across every category. Polymarket’s official fee page describes taker fees on certain markets and differing conditions by category. Check the live contract’s fee status, order type and current schedule immediately before acting. Third-party deposit, withdrawal or conversion costs may also matter. We deliberately do not embed a standing fee rate here: an article cannot keep a changing fee schedule current by itself.

A useful worksheet separates initial cash paid, execution spread, any applicable trade fee, exit price or settlement payout, and outside transfer costs. For the illustrative 100 shares bought at $0.62, purchase cost before fees is $62; a winning $100 settlement would produce $38 gross and a losing settlement would lose $62 gross. This says nothing about the likelihood of either outcome. Expected value needs a defensible probability estimate as well as a cost estimate.

Recheck at decision time

The timestamp of a market display matters. If the displayed probability, order book or fee field is stale or unavailable, label it unavailable rather than silently carrying forward a prior value. Ask whether the intended position can be unwound under poor liquidity. Compare the real executable price with the model’s estimate only after reading the exact resolution rules. A positive paper gap is an invitation to investigate, not a quoted return. See model gap versus ROI for the full arithmetic.